The Stiehl Template Scoring Guide helps you assess whether your intended learning outcomes are clear, realistic, and useful for course design. Strong outcomes make it easier to align assessments, activities, and content. Weak outcomes create confusion for learners and make course planning harder.
Stiehl template scoring guide
Download the Stiehl template scoring guide alongside this job aid.
Core characteristics of good outcome statements
Each dimension of the scoring guide highlights a quality that contributes to effective outcomes. Use these as checkpoints when drafting or revising your statements.
1. Action
Strong outcomes are written in active voice with clear, measurable verbs. The action word should capture what learners will do as a result of the learning experience.
- Strong: “Analyze case studies to identify effective leadership strategies.”
- Weak: “Understand leadership strategies.”
Use Bloom's Taxonomy or other verb lists to select precise actions. Avoid vague verbs like know, learn, or appreciate.
2. Context
Good outcomes describe what learners can apply after and outside the course, not just what they do in the course. Outcomes should reflect transfer to real-world or professional situations.
- Strong: “Design a budget plan for a non-profit organization.”
- Weak: “Complete budgeting exercises in class.”
Ask yourself, "What will learners be able to do beyond this course as a result of this learning?"
3. Scope
Effective outcomes align with the course's timeframe and resources. They are ambitious but realistic.
- Strong: “Write a short research report using APA style.”
- Unrealistic: “Publish original research in a peer-reviewed journal.”
Check that the outcome aligns with the course level and workload. If it's too broad, break it into smaller outcomes.
4. Complexity
As a set, outcomes should have enough substance and depth to guide meaningful teaching decisions. If all outcomes are trivial, they won’t drive learning design.
- Balanced set: Some outcomes target recall, others focus on application, analysis, or creation.
- Unbalanced set: All outcomes are at the “remember” level.
Aim for a variety across levels of cognitive complexity. Use multiple verbs across Bloom's levels.
5. Brevity and clarity
Statements should be concise, unambiguous, and easy to understand. Long or jargon-heavy outcomes confuse learners and stakeholders.
- Strong: “Summarize the main arguments in academic articles.”
- Weak: “Students will gain a broad understanding of and exposure to theoretical and practical perspectives across a variety of academic discourses.”
Keep it short. Use one sentence per outcome. Use plain language.
Problems and fixes
| Problem | Fix |
|---|---|
| Using verbs like understand or learn. | Replace with observable actions like explain, apply, or evaluate. |
| Writing outcomes that are too big to measure. | Break them down into smaller, course-level outcomes. |
| Outcomes focus only on what happens in class. | Frame the around real-world transfer. |
Final thoughts
Good outcome statements are active, contextual, realistic, substantive, and clear. Use the Stiehl Template Scoring Guide as a checklist to refine your drafts. The goal is to produce outcomes that guide teaching decisions and communicate expectations clearly to learners.
How can we help?
Every teaching context is different. Let's start with a conversation about your goals, your learners, and your ideas.
Oki, Âba wathtech, Danit'ada, Tawnshi, Hello.
SAIT is located on the traditional territories of the Niitsitapi (Blackfoot) and the people of Treaty 7 which includes the Siksika, the Piikani, the Kainai, the Tsuut’ina and the Îyârhe Nakoda of Bearspaw, Chiniki and Goodstoney.
We are situated in an area the Blackfoot tribes traditionally called Moh’kinsstis, where the Bow River meets the Elbow River. We now call it the city of Calgary, which is also home to the Métis Nation of Alberta.